
Soviet architecture has a well-deserved reputation for sterility and drabness,
and its statuary is dominated by communist functionaries and military types,
however that doesn't mean that Moscow is an uninteresting place to visit
as a tourist.
Although nazi armies came within artillery range of Moscow during world
war two, the city escaped the catastrophic damage done in central and eastern
Europe, or even in Russian and Ukrainian cities like Leningrad and Stalingrad.
This means that communist architects never had the opportunity to remake
the face of Moscow in the way that they rebuilt cities in Germany, Poland
and other parts of eastern Europe. They did demolish some architectural
treasures in Moscow and certainly set up a large number of statues of Lenin,
Stalin and their ilk, however most of the buildings erected during tsarist
times survived and can still be seen today.
Most people have seen images of communist era statues being torn down and
thrown together in empty plots of ground, awaiting their turn to be melted
down. However, there are still some statues from this period
scattered around the country, including this one of Marshal Zhukov outside
the state history museum at the north end of Red Square. Zhukov
somehow managed to survive the bloody purges Stalin ordered against his
own military forces before world war two, and became the leader of the
Russian forces in a largely unknown war between Russian and Japan in 1939,
and was later appointed to defend Moscow in late 1941 as the Germans closed
in on the city. He was also involved in the battles of Leningrad,
Stalingrad and Kursk.
In this
photo, Zhukov's horse looks shocked and embarassed that it's accidentally
trodden on and broken someone's favourite heirloom. In fact,
it's one of the Nazi eagles that were a common feature of fascist Germany,
a reminder that Zhukov captured Berlin and commanded the Soviet occupation
force in Germany after the war. |
| In
1991 Red Square was added to the UNESCO list of world heritage sites, and
it really acts as the focal point of Moscow and therefore the whole of
Russia. This is a view of the north end of the square - unlike
Times
Square in New York, this really is a square (OK, it's actually a bent
rectangle, but you know what I mean). The lack of people in this
photo is very uncharacteristic, I'm not quite sure how I managed it or
even whether it's a good thing. From left to right in this
photo you can see the domed Senate Building behind the high walls of the
kremlin, with the Senate Tower built into the wall directly behind the
tomb of Lenin. The next structure to the right is the St Nicholas
Tower, with the Corner Arsenal Tower to its right, marking the far northern
corner of the more-or-less triangular kremlin. Again we have
the State History Museum on the right hand side of the photo, with the
Resurrection Gate next to it. |
 |
| Lenin's
body still lies in the tomb where it was placed when he died.
The bodies and ashes of various communist dignitaries and celebrities are
interred under and in the Kremlin wall behind the tomb, including Marshal
Zhukov, cosmonaut Yuri Gagarin and Lenin's lover Inessa Armand.
Stalin shared the tomb with Lenin from 1953 to 1961 until the country's
leaders summoned up the nerve to disavow his tyranny and kick him out.
Although the communist era is over, the tomb is now part of the country's
history and is likely to remain in place for the foreseeable future. |
 |
| Here's
the south end of Red Square, taken on a different day with rather more
clouds and rather more people. Again you can see St Basil's
cathedral at the far end of the square. The name "red" square
didn't come about as a reference to communism, or even to the large amount
of red brickwork around the square, instead it was originally a reference
to St Basil's. The Russian word "krasnaya" can mean either
"beautiful" or "red", and it was the term "beautiful" which was originally
applied to the cathedral, but then shifted in meaning and location to become
Red Square. |
 |

St Basil's cathedral is the iconic building in Russia, and deservedly so.
It's a marvellous piece of architecture with instant appeal to anyone who
sees it, whether they know anything about architecture or not.
This style of church is uniquely Russian and a great introduction to this
whole school of building. The lack of symmetry and consistency
in the towers and domes is very disarming, but the effect of each individual
part and of the whole structure taken together is very pleasing.
There are nine separate chapels, one under each of the onion domes, but
the tall central tower unifies the structure into a single whole.
The
cathedral is old, having been built between 1555 and 1561 to commemorate
Ivan the Terrible's defeat of the Tatar city of Kazan. The
statue in front of the cathedral dates from 1818 and portrays Kuzma Minin
and Dmitry Pozharsky, who drove Polish invaders out of Moscow in 1612,
200 years before the French under Napoleon came to grief in this same place.
This statue was originally in the middle of Red Square, but the communist
government moved it here in 1936 because it was impeding parades.
Basil himself, after whom the cathedral is named, was one of those barefoot
"holy fools" who periodically turn up in Russia, perhaps the most famous
being Rasputin. Basil correctly predicted Ivan's ultimate downfall,
but died while Kazan was still under siege. Somehow the cathedral
ended up named for him, rather than for the victor of the battle which
is commemorated by the cathedral! |
| Almost
all photos of St Basil's show it from the north, but it's equally attractive
viewed from any direction, though unfortunately its lower parts were undergoing
extensive work while I was there. Kazan cathedral at the north
end of the square and the Resurrection Gate were both demolished to allow
military parades to pass through, and they've only been rebuilt in recent
times. It looked as if St Basil's might suffer the same fate,
but fortunately there was enough space to allow traffic past it, and Stalin
himself is said to have intervened, unwilling to allow such a marvellous
piece of architecture to be destroyed. |
 |
| The
large GUM department store dominates the eastern side of Red Square.
GUM was once synonymous with fat cat communists who enjoyed a comparative
life of luxury above the daily grind of ordinary Russians, but much has
changed since that time, and it is now full of very stylish and expensive
European boutiques which allow Russia's fat cat oligarch robber barons
to enjoy a comparative life of luxury above the daily grind of ordinary
Russians. |
 |
| The
acronym GUM stands for "state universal store", but its tsarist name of
"upper trading rows" is perhaps more appropriate, because it doesn't consist
of a single undivided building, but rather three rows of shops, each of
which is built on three levels. At the time of the October
Revolution there were 1200 separate shops in this building, with more in
the "middle trading rows" located across Ilyinka Street, directly to the
south. The far wall in this view is actually a divider, and
there's another stretch of stores of equal length on the other side of
the wall. There are also another two rows of stores just like
this one, which aren't visible in this photo. |
 |
| The
Russian word "kremlin" actually means "fortification", and so there are
many kremlins in Russia, but around the world Moscow's kremlin is referred
to as "the Kremlin". Historically the Moscow Kremlin was the
seat of both political and religious power in Russia, but that changed
in 1712 when Tsar Peter the Great announced that he was moving the capital
to St Petersburg. Moscow didn't regain its primacy until the
communists moved the capital back there in 1918, fearing that St Petersburg
was too vulnerable to invasion. This photo is taken from the
Bol Kamenny bridge over the Moscow river. The tall Water Tower
marks the south-western corner of the Kremlin, the Great Kremlin Palace
is in the center of the photo, and you can see the domes of the Annunciation
Cathedral and Archangel Cathedral next to it, along with the Ivan the Great
Bell Tower and the attached belfry. From 1600 when Boris Godunov
raised its height to 81 meters until the 20th century, the bell tower was
the tallest structure in Moscow. |
 |
| It's
futile to cover the Kremlin in a few photos, so I'm going to set up a separate
page devoted to the things that are within its walls.
However, here's one photo showing the inside of the Assumption Cathedral,
whose walls and ceiling are completely covered in interesting religious
paintings and icons. |
 |
| The
Kremlin is immediately to the west of Red Square, and immediately on the
east side is an historic part of town called Kitai Gorod. It's
an ideal part of town to walk around, with various interesting pieces of
architecture scattered around, like the Church of the Trinity in Nikitniki,
a Russian baroque church built in the 1630s. |
 |

The Monastery of the Epiphany is in the same district, its Epiphany Cathedral
was also built in Russian baroque style, in the 1690s.
It seems surprising that the communists allowed so many cathedrals and
churches to remain standing. Apparently Stalin was somewhat
superstitious, even ordering a special service in one of the Kremlin cathedrals
during the Great Patriotic War in the hope of keeping the encroaching Germans
at bay. His successor Khruschev was apparently more ruthless
as far as the church was concerned.
Both the Epiphany Cathedral and the Church of the Trinity in Nikitniki
were undergoing restoration when I visited in August of 2006, and it literally
seemed that the same was true for about half of all the historic buildings
I saw. This might be partly a consequence of many decades of
neglect and partly a consequence of the severe Moscow climate. |

One church building which didn't survive Stalin was the Cathedral of Christ
the Saviour built from 1839 to 1883 to commemorate the defeat of Napoleon.
Originally envisioned by Tsar Alexander I, its design was redone and a
new location set aside by his brother and successor, Nicholas, before being
consecrated on the day Alexander III was crowned. A year before
that, Tchaikovsky's famous "1812 Overture" debuted in the cathedral.
Stalin decided that he wanted the site for a 315 meter high Palace of the
Soviets, with a 100 meter high statue of Lenin outside. In
1931 Stalin had the cathedral demolished, but the Palace of the Soviets
was never built and instead the location was used for the largest swimming
pool in the world.
Come 1995 and Moscow's go-getting mayor Yury Luzhkov started work on a
replacement Cathedral of Christ the Saviour, completing it in only two
years, but at a cost of US$350 million. Church building and
restoration is certainly a boom industry in Russia, I saw work being done
in all the places I visited. Ordinary Russians seem to have
welcomed orthodox beliefs back into their lives, and the orthodox church
is once again a major part of Russian national identity. |

It's worth doing a boat trip along the Moscow river, but be warned that
the concept of a round trip doesn't exist here. On the mistaken
assumption that I could go down the river and back again on the same ticket,
I ended up spending a ridiculous amount of money to go just three stops.
The best thing to do is to take the subway to one of the end points, such
as Novospassky Most boat landing, and then take the boat to the other end
point.
One building you'll see near Novospassky Most is the Kotelnicheskaya apartment
block, one of Stalin's "Seven Sisters", a group of seven skyscrapers built
in the 1950s in an odd mixture of styles which were supposed to impress
the world with the splendour of Russia's progress and architectural achievements
under communist rule. Instead the Seven Sisters seem more like
a monument to the inferiority complex Russia felt towards America's skyscrapers. |
| Nowadays
Russia has started to find its own voice, and there are some really interesting
buildings being put up, like these ones about a kilometer along the river
from their ugly sister. The one on the right is the Moscow
International Concert Hall, the ones on the left comprise the Riverside
Towers business center. In 2004 Forbes magazine claimed that
there were more billionaires living in Moscow than in other city in the
world - a total of 33, compared to 31 in the runner-up, New York. |
 |

The Lenin Library is another communist monument, and only a short walk
from the main entrance to the Kremlin. Its squat Soviet Realistic
exterior didn't induce me to go inside, but I took a photo anyway since
it's right next to the subway station I used whenever I visited Red Square
and the Kremlin.
I'm not too knowledgeable about Russian communists, but I certainly know
that the statue isn't of Lenin - looks more like Karl Marx to me. |
The subway is certainly the best way to get around, and is fairly easy
to navigate even if you don't have much in the way of Russian language
skills. It's fairly clean, trains are very frequent and they
can take you anywhere you'd want to go in this large city.
After getting his start in the mines of the Ukraine, the man who became
Premier Khruschev was assigned to oversee the construction of the subway
system, and by all accounts he did a very good job.
The stations still carry their original names, this photo was taken in
the "Proletariat station" and there are other stations named for the 1905
revolution, the barricades set up during the October revolution and Lubyanka,
which is where the notorious and dreaded KGB prison was located. |
| It's
well worth using the subway to explore parts of Moscow beyond the central
area. There are many large parks and historic estates which
can be visited, as well as literary and other cultural sites.
I was only in the country for about 10 days so I had to limit the number
of places within Moscow I visited, because I wanted to go outside Moscow
to the historic towns of the so-called "Golden Ring", and I had also set
aside several days to photograph the
2005 MAKS airshow and to visit the
Russian air force museum at Monino. One place within Moscow
I was determined to visit was Novodevichy convent, which you see here. |
 |

The convent was founded in 1524 to commemorate the recapture of the Russian
town of Smolensk from the Lithuanians. As well as being a convent
it was also intended as a fortress, which is why it has crenulated towers.
It became a favoured place for noble women to seek a religious life, and
was also used more or less as a prison for politically inconvenient women,
such as Tsar Peter the Great's first wife, and also for his half-sister.
It's association with nobility made the convent very wealthy, and it ended
up owning a huge area of land, a large number of villages and about 14,500
serfs. With the church acting in this way it's not too surprising
that communism was able to take root in Russia by proclaiming the "dictatorship
of the proletariat", nor is it surprising that communism was so hostile
towards religion.
There are quite a few interesting buildings within the grounds of the convent,
such as the Transfiguration Gate Church which you see here, built between
1687 and 1689. The church actually sits above the gate which
it's named after. |

This unusual squat structure is the Prokhorov chapel. The bell
tower which you can see behind it is widely considered to be the finest
in all of Moscow. It is octagonal and has six tiers, and for
a long time it was the second tallest structure in Moscow, after the Ivan
the Great bell tower.
As you can see there are quite a few tombs within the grounds of the convent,
including Sofia and Peter the Great's wife. |
| The
bell tower again, this time with the Smolensk Cathedral which is said to
be modelled after the Assumption Cathedral within the Kremlin. |
 |
| Novodevichy
convent is also famous for its cemetery, which is the main reason I visited.
Just as the convent was associated with noble women, so the cemetery became
the final resting place for nobility, both men and women. It
became the burial place of many elite members of society, both in tsarist
times and during the communist era. |
 |
| I
was largely interested in visiting because this is the burial place of
Andrei Tupolev, the ingenious and prolific Russian aircraft designer.
I also wanted to see the graves of a couple of the Russian composers whose
music I listen to, Prokofiev and Shostakovich. There are other
cultural luminaries here, such as the writers Gogol and Chekov, as well
as a fair number of Soviet era military types, including this guy who decided
to take his tank with him! |
 |

As I mentioned earlier, the premier burial place for Russia's communist
elite is the area in and under the Kremlin wall behind Lenin's tomb, but
Novodevichy was used for many of the lesser lights, as well as a few who
were very prominent but became politically inconvenient at some point.
Chief amongst this latter group of people is Nikita Khruschev, who managed
to survive and ascend the political ladder during the bloody and lunatic
reign of Stalin, and who then clawed his way to the top during the power
struggle that followed Stalin's death.
The black and white blocks surrounding Khruschev's bust are symbolic of
the mixed feelings Russians have towards him, and of the very public good
and bad aspects of his personality. Like all of Stalin's henchmen
he participated and even orchestrated purges of people Stalin perceived
to be political enemies, so he certainly had a great deal of blood on his
hands. However, he also showed his very real humanity and compassion
throughout this entire period, protecting some people he felt deserved
it and showing real empathy to people like Stalin's daughter Svetlana who
was treated very coldly by her father, and ended up defecting.
It was also Khruschev who made the decisive break with Stalin by denouncing
his actions and policies in the so-called Secret Speech given at the 20th
party congress in 1956, three years after Stalin's death. This
might have been a somewhat pre-emptive and forced action on Khruschev's
part, but there's no doubting that he sincerely felt that Stalin's actions
while in power were wrong, and it took a lot of courage in the dog-eat-dog
world of communist politics to stand up and be counted by flatly contradicting
the many years of propaganda that had built up Stalin's personality cult
by portraying him as the wise and benevolent father of the country.
This campaign had been so successful that even political prisoners imprisoned
in the gulags had broken down weeping when they heard the news of Stalin's
death, believing that Stalin's corrupt cronies had been responsible for
their imprisonment, rather than Stalin himself.
It was Khruschev who caused the release of many thousands of political
prisoners, however in 1964 his own flaws caught up with him.
The Politburo had grown tired of his erratic policies, his uneducated crudeness
and embarassing international buffoonery, most notably the occasion on
which he pounded on his desk with his shoe in the United Nations general
assembly. It was a measure of the improved political climate
under Khruschev that he was allowed to retire quietly to private life,
rather than being lined up against a wall and shot as an enemy of the people
on trumped-up evidence. |
See
the Highlights
of the 2005 MAKS Airshow, Highlights
of the 2006 Gidroaviasalon Airshow, the Russian
Air
Force Museum at Monino or the Bugs
of Russia.
 |